The Most Beautiful Café in Nutley, NJ

Sugar Tree Cafe

358 Passaic Ave Nutley, NJ 07110

Recently stopped by to enjoy a sweet treat and some coffee and I was not disappointed! Sugar Tree Cafe has such a beautiful interior and welcoming vibe. Definitely the perfect spot if you're looking for a brunch-type menu with Instagram-able decor. The staff was also very friendly and ensured quick service.

Instead of physical menus, they offer a QR code to easily navigate their options. I decided to go with ordering the Sticky Bun and an Iced French Vanilla Latte with almond milk. The latte was definitely a 5/5 due to the amazingly strong coffee flavor and sweet addition of french vanilla. I was very happy to find that they offer dairy-free milk options, as well. The Sticky Bun was also delicious and had many flaky layers inside! I rate it a 4/5 since I think it would have been even better heated up!

Click to View on Yelp

My sister ordered the Nitro Fries (Cajun seasoned, fried with rosemary and thyme with a side of hazelnut coffee Aioli) and Strawberry Vegan Shake (ice cream and fresh strawberries on a bed of fresh strawberries topped with whipped cream strawberry syrup and a vegan cookie), so you know I tried her food as well! The fries were fresh, hot & crispy and seasoned very well. I was unfortunately not the biggest fan of the coffee aioli, but the fries did not need a sauce at all! I rate them a 4/5. The Strawberry Vegan Shake was also delicious and the whipped cream on top tasted just like cool-whip. I would definitely recommend and I rate the shake a 4/5!

Overall, I found Sugar Tree Cafe to be a solid option for those who want to hang out at a beautiful and comfy cafe with some coffee and a nice treat. Would definitely stop by again whenever I'm in the neighborhood :)

Rating: ★★★★☆